All menu items reflect cash prices. 3.99% will be added to all non-cash transactions.



Chocolate Old Fashioned 14
Knob Creek bourbon, creme de cacao, simple syrup, chocolate bitters, orange peel and amareno cherry

Chocolate Cherry Martini 13
Haku vodka, chocolate liquor, cherry syrup, cream, garnished with chocolate


Smoked Tomato & Chocolate Soup 13
Roma tomatoes, crispy pancetta, chocolate caramelized onions

Housemade Pretzel Knots 12
Served with cooper cheese sauce and chocolate custard


Chicken Mole Sandwich 16
Pulled mole chicken, shredded lettuce, pickled red onion, avocado, cotija cheese, served on telera bread


Triple Chocolate Mousse 12
Chocolate shortbread, passion fruit caramel, blackberry coulis

Dutch Chocolate Pretzel Ice Cream 8


Buffalo Cauliflower Bites 11 (V)
Fried cauliflower, house buffalo sauce, crumbled bleu cheese, bleu cheese dressing

Charcuterie & Cheese 23
Cured meats, artisanal cheeses, glazed walnuts, local honey, marmalade, whole grain mustard

Roasted Apple Flatbread 15
Ricotta cheese, baked apples, fresh greens, spicy honey

Johnny Cakes & Shrimp Creole 16
Griddled corn cakes with etouffee-style shrimp

Littleneck Clams 17
Garlic & white wine broth, finished with fresh oregano, grilled bread

Fried Chicken 14
Buttermilk marinade, house grilled cornbread, bourbon-honey syrup


French Onion Soup 11
Vidalia onions, croutons

Caesar Salad 12
Baby romaine, parmesan crisp, house crouton

Apple Salad 14 V GF
Apples, crumbled bleu cheese, candied walnuts, grapes, Bibb lettuce, cider vinaigrette

House Salad 14
Chickpeas, tomato, cucumbers, hearts of palm, sherry-shallot vinaigrette

Filet 28 / Single Crab Cake 15
Grilled Chicken 8 / Shrimp 11


Chicken Pot Pye 21
Roasted chicken, garden vegetables, velouté, pie crust

Beef Burgundy 27
Short rib, pearl onions, mushrooms, tuscan bread

Roasted Turkey Dinner 23
Mashed potatoes, cranberry relish, stuffing, gravy

Palermo Rigatoni 24
Grilled chicken, 3-hour onions, old world blush sauce

Butternut Squash Risotto 18
Crispy shiitake, parmesan, squash puree

Crab Cakes 31
Twin crab cakes, sweet potato hash, smoked almond puree, kale apple salad


Sub “Beyond Burger” +$2

The Bull Burger 14
Vermont cheddar, shredded lettuce, Pa’s smothered onions, seeded roll, fries

Dutch Burger 17
Custom butcher’s blend 8 oz. patty, smoked gouda, roasted garlic aioli, lettuce, fried pickles, seeded roll

Shaved Pork Sandwich 15
Shaved Italian roast pork, pork jus, braised escarole, sharp provolone, grilled ciabatta

Lancaster Pastrami 15
House-smoked Pastrami, beer-braised sauerkraut, dijonnaise, Swiss cheese and toasted rye, fries

The Montague 14
Turkey breast, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, toasted rye bread, chips

Crab Cake Sandwich 17
Lettuce, celery root slaw, artisan flatbread, chips

Garlic Grilled Chicken 14
Provolone, garlic aioli, braised greens, seeded roll, fries

Short Rib Grilled Cheese 17
Pulled short ribs, garlic & herb spread, cheddar cheese, red onion jam, Texas toast, fries

Chicken Salad Sandwich 13
House-brined chicken, lettuce, tomato, artisan flatbread, chips


All kids meals include french fries, a beverage & ice cream

Cheeseburger 9

Hot Dog 9

Chicken Tenders 9

Grilled Cheese 9

Mac ‘n Cheese 9


Cinnamon Rice Pudding 10 GF
Chai-spiced fruits, almond florentine

Vanilla Cheesecake 10
Whipped cream, seasonal accompaniment

Brownie Sundae 10
Pretzel crusted brownie, toasted marshmallow sauce, coffee caramel, brown butter rice krispies, vanilla ice cream

Hummingbird Cake 10
Banana pineapple cake, toasted pecans, cream cheese frosting

Amish Apple Fritter Bread 10
Bourbon anglaise, whipped cream, apple chip

Creamsicle Budino 10 GF
Orange budino, vanilla bean panna cotta, white chocolate crumble


Ask about our additional cocktails and spirits

Signature Cocktails

Classic Cosmo 12
Tito’s vodka, cranberry, triple sec, fresh lime

Margarita 12
Hornitos Plata tequila, triple sec, fresh lime, salt or no

The Manhattan 15
Overholt rye, Carpano Antica, amarena cherry

Earl’s Collins 12
Haku vodka, Lillet, raspberry syrup, lemon juice, club soda


Cider Mimosa 12
Prosecco, local cider

Silver Fox 13
Knob Creek bourbon, pear liqueur, Earl Grey syrup, muddled blackberries

Seasonal Sangria 12
Please ask your server

Peddler’s Punch 5 n/a
Local cider infused with seasonal fruit, topped with ginger ale